The Price of Utopia: Universal Basic Income

Utopia often stands for an ideal society with harmony and equality. Sir Thomas More’s ‘Utopia (1516)’ set the centuries-long debate of its feasibility (Mangeloja and Ovaska, 2019). The core of More’s utopia claims that justice is established through communal property rather than private possession. The vision may remain theoretical, but the aspiration is continued in the modern suggestion. The universal basic income (UBI) is designed to build an economic utopia grounded in equality (Widerquist, 2024).

The idea of UBI first emerged in the 18th century as a response to the growing social inequality (Widerquist, 2024). The enclosure movement excluded many from their livelihood, prompting suggestions of radical redistribution of wealth through the reformers such as Thomas Paine and Thomas Spence. Paine argued for capital granted to all adults in ‘Agrarian Justice (1797)’, and Spence suggested periodic payment for every citizen in ‘The Rights of Infants (1797)’. Despite the differences, both saw the communal basic income as a necessity of a more just society.

The contemporary definition of UBI shares the equalitarian logic. The International Monetary Fund describes UBI as regular payments to a given population with no requirements (Francese and Prady). The Stanford Basic Income Lab argues on true universal nature of it. Widerquist (2024:29) further specifies the definition of UBI as ‘a non-means-tested form of income guaranteed’. The fundamental of all definitions is the guaranteed periodic, unconditional income of equal size for every individual.

Yet implementing the theory into practise has proven complex. Two notable examples are the Alaska Permanent Fund and the Finnish 2017-2018 national experiment. From the 1976 constitution amendment mandating 25% of mineral revenue to the fund, APF provided annual dividends of around $1000 and $3000 per resident (APFC). Similarly, the conducted Finnish experiment guaranteed a €560 monthly income for 2000 unemployed residents (Nagesh, 2019).

Both trials demonstrated tangible social benefits. In Alaska, researchers found between 15,000 and 25,000 residents lifted from poverty annually; especially rural residents, indigenous, and small businesses benefited (Berman and Reamey, 2016). Finnish participants reported significantly improved mental health and increased trust in the politicians (Henley, 2020)—the response provides both psychological and material benefits of UBI.

However, the philosophical promise of UBI contradicts economic reality. The funding is UBI’s major obstacle. Few societies possess Alaska’s unique mineral wealth, and an additional taxation model may lead to fiscal neutrality and the absence of increased standards of living with increased tax or the removal of other welfare benefits. OECD warns that the policy simply redistributes scarcity, rather than eliminating it (2017). Without sustainable financial support, UBI may violate Rawlsian Theory (Wallace, 2022)’s efficiency, disregarding the theoretically enhanced equality.

Thus, the UBI occupies the midground of idealism and pragmatism. The utopia is yet to come, but humanity’s investigation of equality is integrated into the UBI. Like More’s original vision, UBI asks whether justice can coexist with inequality, and whether economic policy can integrate the philosophical utopia.

This essay has been awarded the Runner-Up from 2026 Immerse Education Essay Competition. Please refer to the individual hyperlinks to view the cited works.

Leave a Reply